How a jury reaches a verdict, the monks who bred mountain rescuers and how a tiny nation became a rugby superpower

Welcome back to ‘A Little Wiser’ newsletter. We hope everyone had a lovely weekend. Grab your coffee and let’s dive into today’s knowledge.

⚖️ How a Jury Reaches a Verdict

When a jury files into the deliberation room, twelve ordinary citizens suddenly become a temporary parliament charged with delivering a unanimous decision that can change lives. Once sworn in, your job is to decide whether the prosecution has proven its case beyond reasonable doubt. That standard is deliberately heavy and leans toward protecting the accused, not satisfying the public. Deliberations begin with the task of electing a foreperson whose job is to ensure everyone’s opinion gets heard and ultimately sign the verdict form that seals the decision. Jurors then take their first vote which is usually informal and anonymous to see where the room stands. People argue from memory, emotion, personal experience, and whatever notes they managed to take.

Behind the closed door of the deliberation room, human psychology becomes the thirteenth juror. Groups fracture, alliances form, and strong personalities often take control of discussions. Some jurors want to vote immediately while others insist on rereading every scrap of evidence. In the 1995 O.J. Simpson case, the jury took only four hours to deliver a verdict on nine months of testimony, prompting critics to argue they’d made up their minds before entering the room. If deliberations collapse and the jury deadlocks, the judge may declare a mistrial. In the 2014 trial of Michael Dunn, the jurors agreed he was guilty of attempted murder for firing into a car of unarmed teenagers but deadlocked for 30 hours over the central question of first-degree murder. The stalemate produced a mistrial on the most serious charge and revealed how different people can look at identical testimony and reach incompatible emotional conclusions. And then there is the 2017 deliberation in Bill Cosby’s first sexual-assault trial which stretched to 52 hours. The case ended as a mistrial, not because the facts changed, but because the room could not converge on a single narrative.

Even getting into the jury box is a drama of its own. During voir dire, the questioning phase, lawyers can challenge potential jurors “for cause” (clear bias or conflict) or use a limited number of peremptory challenges to remove people based on instinct alone. In the 1957 trial of mafia boss Vito Genovese, prosecutors struck every juror who had even faint connections to Italian neighborhoods. Once you’re picked, the responsibility is absolute: you can’t Google the case, discuss it with family, or even react online. Juries are imperfect and emotional but they remain one of the few places where ordinary citizens hold direct power over the state. The jury room remains a stubborn reminder that justice, at its core, is still a conversation among citizens.

British study finds jurors struggle to understand judges (source: Ministry of Justice - BBC)

⛰️ The Monks Who Bred Mountain Rescuers

The Great St. Bernard Pass stands high in the Alps on the ancient trade route connecting Switzerland and Italy. This corridor was so treacherous that a traveler could be swallowed by winter storms without warning. For centuries, the only lifeline across this frozen frontier was the Great St. Bernard Hospice, a monastery founded by Augustinian canons nearly a thousand years ago. The monks here offered more than just shelter and hot broth; they ran a sophisticated rescue operation in one of Europe’s deadliest landscapes. To fulfill this critical mission, they strategically bred a dog that would become one of the world's most iconic mountain guardians.

The St. Bernard was not created for cuddles or postcard charm. The monks selectively bred a line of powerful, broad-chested dogs capable of navigating deep snow and surviving conditions that would stop the most seasoned mountaineers. They possessed an uncanny ability to predict avalanches and sense the faint human scent carried on the wind, allowing them to locate victims buried under several meters of snow. Early travel diaries describe teams of these dogs patrolling the pass, digging out buried pilgrims, and warming them with their sheer body heat. The famous brandy barrel around the neck may be more legend than fact, but the purpose behind the myth is true. These dogs were, quite literally, holy first responders. The most famous among them was Barry, who lived from 1800 to 1812 and is credited with saving more than 40 lives during his service. His body is preserved and displayed at the Natural History Museum in Bern, a monument to the most celebrated rescue dog in history.

But by the 1830s, despite their heroic efforts, the breed faced near extinction due to severe winters and disease. The monks introduced crossbreeding with Newfoundlands to increase size and improve cold resistance. This created the long-haired variety we recognize today, though paradoxically, these dogs proved less effective for mountain rescue as ice would cling to their fur. By the 19th century, the St. Bernard's reputation had spread across Europe, and the dogs became symbols of Swiss heroism and monastic devotion. They were bred by clergy, trained in a monastery, and deployed to protect the vulnerable on a perilous border crossing. Over the centuries, they saved more than 2,000 people, a record unmatched by any other rescue tradition of the era. Today, the pass is safer and helicopters do the work once done by paws and intuition, but the St. Bernard endures in the cultural imagination as a gentle giant with a sacred past.

A Monk of the Grand St. Bernard with two of his loyal, life-saving St. Bernards

🏉 How a Tiny Nation Became a Rugby Superpower

Despite its small population of just over 5 million people, New Zealand's All Blacks are widely considered the most dominant team in the history of rugby. Since 1903, the team has lost to only seven countries, maintaining a comfortable winning record against every single opponent they have faced in test matches. For New Zealand, rugby is a national obsession, transforming the sport into a "game for everyone", and, crucially, drawing strength from the entire South Pacific region to create an unparalleled pool of talent.

The All Blacks' power stems from a deep cultural integration that embraces the wider Pasifika community. The game's accessibility in New Zealand ensured that the indigenous Māori population was immediately involved, fusing the sport with native traditions like the iconic Haka. Following World War II, New Zealand experienced significant waves of migration from neighboring Polynesian islands like Samoa, Tonga, and Fiji, many of whom came seeking work opportunities. Furthermore, the populations of the Cook Islands and Niue hold New Zealand citizenship due to historical administration, granting them automatic access to the New Zealand rugby system and culture. This continuous flow of powerful, athletic talent from the broader South Pacific sphere supplies an incomparable advantage, giving the All Blacks access to players like legendary captain Tana Umaga, who helped usher in a new era of Polynesian-driven flair in New Zealand rugby.

This continuous excellence is secured by an unmatched national talent pipeline built to absorb and refine that regional talent. The system begins at the earliest age, with programs like Rippa Rugby for five and six-year-olds, teaching foundational skills while maximizing participation across the entire population. The top players filter through a highly competitive high school system and then into the professional domestic league, Super Rugby. Crucially, the New Zealand Rugby Union mandates that only players competing within the domestic system are eligible for the All Blacks squad. This strict policy ensures that the country maintains control over its development strategy, consistently producing multi-skilled superstars. This robust system is what allowed players like legendary flanker Richie McCaw and tactical strategist Daniel Carter to develop and define the "greatest generation of All Blacks ever".

New Zealand’s amazing rugby win rates year on year

We hope you enjoyed today’s edition. Thank you to everyone reading, sharing, and helping A Little Wiser reach new people every week. We value every reader so please reply and tell us a lesson you’d love to see soon!

Until next time…. - A Little Wiser Team

🕮 Three lessons. Three times a week. Three minutes at a time.
💌 Enjoyed this edition? Share it with someone curious.

Keep Reading

No posts found