
Welcome back to A Little Wiser. We hope your week is going well. On this day in 1985, Microsoft released Windows 1.0, the very first version. Today’s wisdom explores:
✦
Why the Internet Can’t Be Switched Off
✦
The Tax That Bricked Up the Windows
✦
The Banana Is Living on Borrowed Time
✦
Grab your coffee and let’s dive in.
TECHNOLOGY
🌐 Why the Internet Can’t Be Switched Off
The internet was built with no off switch, on purpose, by people bracing for nuclear war. When American researchers designed the internet’s ancestor, a network called ARPANET, they wanted a communication system that could survive having large chunks of it destroyed by a Soviet attack. The old telephone system was hopelessly fragile for this, because it relied on central switching offices, and knocking out a few of them could sever an entire region. So the designers built something with no center at all, a web with countless paths between any two points. If one route was bombed into rubble, a message could simply find another way around. That single design choice is the reason no government, company, or person today can flip a switch and turn the whole thing off.
This works because of something called packet switching. When you send anything across the internet, an email, a video, a message, it is not sent as one continuous stream down a single wire. Instead it is chopped into small chunks called packets, and each packet is fired off separately, finding its own route through whatever paths happen to be open at that instant, before all the pieces are reassembled at the destination. This means the internet is not really a thing you could unplug but a set of rules, a shared language that millions of independent machines agree to speak. Those machines are owned by thousands of separate companies, universities, and governments across every country on Earth. To truly kill the global internet, you would need all of them to shut down at the same moment, which is about as likely as every phone company in the world agreeing to hang up at once.
This does not mean the internet is untouchable, and the limits of its resilience are worth knowing. A government that controls the internet service providers inside its own borders can indeed cut off its own citizens, which is exactly what Egypt did in January 2011. Facing mass protests, President Mubarak’s regime ordered the country’s providers to go dark and disconnected roughly 88 percent of Egyptian networks for five days. Yet even this proved the point rather than disproving it, because the global internet carried on without a flicker, utterly indifferent to Egypt’s absence. Egyptians found workarounds using old dial-up connections to foreign providers and fax machines to route information back out to the world. The network, as one writer put it, is made out of people, and people route around damage too. There is a newer worry, though. As more and more of the world’s traffic funnels through a handful of giant companies and a few massive chokepoints, the internet grows more centralized than its founders intended. In a truly decentralized web, a kill switch would require a thousand separate interventions and still might fail. In a centralized one, it could one day be a single line of code. The internet cannot be switched off because it was built with no switch, and the real question for the future is whether we are, bit by bit, building one in.

✦
ECONOMICS
🏠 The Tax That Bricked Up the Windows
Walk around almost any old British town and you will spot them, windows that are not windows at all, their openings neatly filled in with brick or stone while the frame around them survives. They are the fossilized evidence of one of the strangest taxes in history, and of the lengths people will go to avoid paying it. In 1696, King William III was short of money, burdened by the costs of revolution and a war with France. He needed a way to tax people according to their wealth. Asking citizens to declare their income was considered an unacceptable intrusion, so the government reached for a clever proxy. A bigger, grander house tended to have more windows, so the number of windows became a rough measure of how rich you were, and the government decided to tax houses by counting them.
The trouble with taxing windows is that, unlike income, windows can be removed. Faced with a bill that rose with every pane of glass, people across England and Scotland did the obvious thing and simply got rid of the windows they were being charged for, bricking up the openings to drop their house into a lower tax band or below an exemption threshold entirely. A blocked-up opening did not count, so sealing a window was a permanent cut to the tax on every window that remained. The effect on the architecture of the country was dramatic and lasting, with the historical record showing that by 1766 the number of homes with seven or more windows, the point where a higher charge kicked in, had fallen by more than half. New houses were deliberately designed with as few windows as possible, and wealthy owners sealed up perfectly good ones to save money. The economists who later studied the window tax treat it as a textbook example of a destructive levy, one that changed people’s behavior so heavily that it damaged the thing being taxed while raising less money than hoped.
The real victims, as so often, were the poor. The cheapest housing was in tenement blocks, and because an entire tenement counted as a single dwelling under the tax, a building packed with struggling families could carry a huge window bill, which the landlord avoided by bricking up the windows of the crowded rooms where people actually lived. The result was dark, airless lodgings stripped of sunlight and ventilation. By the nineteenth century doctors and reformers were arguing that the tax was quite literally making people sick, worsening the spread of disease in exactly the places that could least afford it. Critics raged that the government was taxing light and air themselves, two things no one should have to pay for. After decades of mounting protest the window tax was finally repealed on 24 July 1851 and replaced with a tax on inhabited houses. Many of those bricked-up windows were later reopened, but a great many were never touched again, and they remain visible on old buildings across Britain to this day.

✦
FOOD
🍌 The Banana Is Living on Borrowed Time
Subscribe to The Athenaeum to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber of The Athenaeum to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
UpgradeAlready a subscriber? Sign in
A subscription gets you:
- 9 topics covered a week
- Every lesson, in one searchable library
- Audio versions of every edition
- Sources and further reading on every lesson
- A monthly deep-dive essay
- Members' community coming soon
- $300+ in partner perks

